Blood borders How a better Middle East would look BY RALPH PETERS .in :armedforcesjournal.com/juin 2006

http://www.armedforcesjournal.com/juin 2006

Blood borders

How a better Middle East would look

BY RALPH PETERS

International borders are never completely just. But the degree of injustice they inflict upon those whom frontiers force together or separate makes an enormous difference — often the difference between freedom and oppression, tolerance and atrocity, the rule of law and terrorism, or even peace and war.

The most arbitrary and distorted borders in the world are in Africa and the Middle East. Drawn by self-interested Europeans (who have had sufficient trouble defining their own frontiers), Africa’s borders continue to provoke the deaths of millions of local inhabitants. But the unjust borders in the Middle East — to borrow from Churchill — generate more trouble than can be consumed locally.

While the Middle East has far more problems than dysfunctional borders alone — from cultural stagnation through scandalous inequality to deadly religious extremism — the greatest taboo in striving to understand the region’s comprehensive failure isn’t Islam but the awful-but-sacrosanct international boundaries worshipped by our own diplomats.

Of course, no adjustment of borders, however draconian, could make every minority in the Middle East happy. In some instances, ethnic and religious groups live intermingled and have intermarried. Elsewhere, reunions based on blood or belief might not prove quite as joyous as their current proponents expect. The boundaries projected in the maps accompanying this article redress the wrongs suffered by the most significant “cheated” population groups, such as the Kurds, Baluch and Arab Shia, but still fail to account adequately for Middle Eastern Christians, Bahais, Ismailis, Naqshbandis and many another numerically lesser minorities. And one haunting wrong can never be redressed with a reward of territory: the genocide perpetrated against the Armenians by the dying Ottoman Empire.

Yet, for all the injustices the borders re-imagined here leave unaddressed, without such major boundary revisions, we shall never see a more peaceful Middle East.

Even those who abhor the topic of altering borders would be well-served to engage in an exercise that attempts to conceive a fairer, if still imperfect, amendment of national boundaries between the Bosporus and the Indus. Accepting that international statecraft has never developed effective tools — short of war — for readjusting faulty borders, a mental effort to grasp the Middle East’s “organic” frontiers nonetheless helps us understand the extent of the difficulties we face and will continue to face. We are dealing with colossal, man-made deformities that will not stop generating hatred and violence until they are corrected.

As for those who refuse to “think the unthinkable,” declaring that boundaries must not change and that’s that, it pays to remember that boundaries have never stopped changing through the centuries. Borders have never been static, and many frontiers, from Congo through Kosovo to the Caucasus, are changing even now (as ambassadors and special representatives avert their eyes to study the shine on their wingtips).

Oh, and one other dirty little secret from 5,000 years of history: Ethnic cleansing works.

Begin with the border issue most sensitive to American readers: For Israel to have any hope of living in reasonable peace with its neighbors, it will have to return to its pre-1967 borders — with essential local adjustments for legitimate security concerns. But the issue of the territories surrounding Jerusalem, a city stained with thousands of years of blood, may prove intractable beyond our lifetimes. Where all parties have turned their god into a real-estate tycoon, literal turf battles have a tenacity unrivaled by mere greed for oil wealth or ethnic squabbles. So let us set aside this single overstudied issue and turn to those that are studiously ignored.

The most glaring injustice in the notoriously unjust lands between the Balkan Mountains and the Himalayas is the absence of an independent Kurdish state. There are between 27 million and 36 million Kurds living in contiguous regions in the Middle East (the figures are imprecise because no state has ever allowed an honest census). Greater than the population of present-day Iraq, even the lower figure makes the Kurds the world’s largest ethnic group without a state of its own. Worse, Kurds have been oppressed by every government controlling the hills and mountains where they’ve lived since Xenophon’s day.

The U.S. and its coalition partners missed a glorious chance to begin to correct this injustice after Baghdad’s fall. A Frankenstein’s monster of a state sewn together from ill-fitting parts, Iraq should have been divided into three smaller states immediately. We failed from cowardice and lack of vision, bullying Iraq’s Kurds into supporting the new Iraqi government — which they do wistfully as a quid pro quo for our good will. But were a free plebiscite to be held, make no mistake: Nearly 100 percent of Iraq’s Kurds would vote for independence.

As would the long-suffering Kurds of Turkey, who have endured decades of violent military oppression and a decades-long demotion to “mountain Turks” in an effort to eradicate their identity. While the Kurdish plight at Ankara’s hands has eased somewhat over the past decade, the repression recently intensified again and the eastern fifth of Turkey should be viewed as occupied territory. As for the Kurds of Syria and Iran, they, too, would rush to join an independent Kurdistan if they could. The refusal by the world’s legitimate democracies to champion Kurdish independence is a human-rights sin of omission far worse than the clumsy, minor sins of commission that routinely excite our media. And by the way: A Free Kurdistan, stretching from Diyarbakir through Tabriz, would be the most pro-Western state between Bulgaria and Japan.

A just alignment in the region would leave Iraq’s three Sunni-majority provinces as a truncated state that might eventually choose to unify with a Syria that loses its littoral to a Mediterranean-oriented Greater Lebanon: Phoenecia reborn. The Shia south of old Iraq would form the basis of an Arab Shia State rimming much of the Persian Gulf. Jordan would retain its current territory, with some southward expansion at Saudi expense. For its part, the unnatural state of Saudi Arabia would suffer as great a dismantling as Pakistan.

A root cause of the broad stagnation in the Muslim world is the Saudi royal family’s treatment of Mecca and Medina as their fiefdom. With Islam’s holiest shrines under the police-state control of one of the world’s most bigoted and oppressive regimes — a regime that commands vast, unearned oil wealth — the Saudis have been able to project their Wahhabi vision of a disciplinarian, intolerant faith far beyond their borders. The rise of the Saudis to wealth and, consequently, influence has been the worst thing to happen to the Muslim world as a whole since the time of the Prophet, and the worst thing to happen to Arabs since the Ottoman (if not the Mongol) conquest.

While non-Muslims could not effect a change in the control of Islam’s holy cities, imagine how much healthier the Muslim world might become were Mecca and Medina ruled by a rotating council representative of the world’s major Muslim schools and movements in an Islamic Sacred State — a sort of Muslim super-Vatican — where the future of a great faith might be debated rather than merely decreed. True justice — which we might not like — would also give Saudi Arabia’s coastal oil fields to the Shia Arabs who populate that subregion, while a southeastern quadrant would go to Yemen. Confined to a rump Saudi Homelands Independent Territory around Riyadh, the House of Saud would be capable of far less mischief toward Islam and the world.

Iran, a state with madcap boundaries, would lose a great deal of territory to Unified Azerbaijan, Free Kurdistan, the Arab Shia State and Free Baluchistan, but would gain the provinces around Herat in today’s Afghanistan — a region with a historical and linguistic affinity for Persia. Iran would, in effect, become an ethnic Persian state again, with the most difficult question being whether or not it should keep the port of Bandar Abbas or surrender it to the Arab Shia State.

What Afghanistan would lose to Persia in the west, it would gain in the east, as Pakistan’s Northwest Frontier tribes would be reunited with their Afghan brethren (the point of this exercise is not to draw maps as we would like them but as local populations would prefer them). Pakistan, another unnatural state, would also lose its Baluch territory to Free Baluchistan. The remaining “natural” Pakistan would lie entirely east of the Indus, except for a westward spur near Karachi.

The city-states of the United Arab Emirates would have a mixed fate — as they probably will in reality. Some might be incorporated in the Arab Shia State ringing much of the Persian Gulf (a state more likely to evolve as a counterbalance to, rather than an ally of, Persian Iran). Since all puritanical cultures are hypocritical, Dubai, of necessity, would be allowed to retain its playground status for rich debauchees. Kuwait would remain within its current borders, as would Oman.

In each case, this hypothetical redrawing of boundaries reflects ethnic affinities and religious communalism — in some cases, both. Of course, if we could wave a magic wand and amend the borders under discussion, we would certainly prefer to do so selectively. Yet, studying the revised map, in contrast to the map illustrating today’s boundaries, offers some sense of the great wrongs borders drawn by Frenchmen and Englishmen in the 20th century did to a region struggling to emerge from the humiliations and defeats of the 19th century.

Correcting borders to reflect the will of the people may be impossible. For now. But given time — and the inevitable attendant bloodshed — new and natural borders will emerge. Babylon has fallen more than once.

Meanwhile, our men and women in uniform will continue to fight for security from terrorism, for the prospect of democracy and for access to oil supplies in a region that is destined to fight itself. The current human divisions and forced unions between Ankara and Karachi, taken together with the region’s self-inflicted woes, form as perfect a breeding ground for religious extremism, a culture of blame and the recruitment of terrorists as anyone could design. Where men and women look ruefully at their borders, they look enthusiastically for enemies.

From the world’s oversupply of terrorists to its paucity of energy supplies, the current deformations of the Middle East promise a worsening, not an improving, situation. In a region where only the worst aspects of nationalism ever took hold and where the most debased aspects of religion threaten to dominate a disappointed faith, the U.S., its allies and, above all, our armed forces can look for crises without end. While Iraq may provide a counterexample of hope — if we do not quit its soil prematurely — the rest of this vast region offers worsening problems on almost every front.

If the borders of the greater Middle East cannot be amended to reflect the natural ties of blood and faith, we may take it as an article of faith that a portion of the bloodshed in the region will continue to be our own.

• • •

WHO WINS, WHO LOSES

Winners

Afghanistan

Arab Shia State

Armenia

Azerbaijan

Free Baluchistan

Free Kurdistan

Iran

Islamic Sacred State

Jordan

Lebanon

Yemen

Losers —

Afghanistan

Iran

Iraq

Israel

Kuwait

Pakistan

Qatar

Saudi Arabia

Syria

Turkey

United Arab Emirates

West Bank

Ralph Peters is the author of the new book “Never Quit the Fight,” to be published on July 4th

5  197 Réponses à “Blood borders How a better Middle East would look BY RALPH PETERS .in :armedforcesjournal.com/juin 2006”

  1. Shanna dit :

    femme de ménage Boucherville, femme de ménage Brossard
    ,femme de ménage Repentigny ,femme de ménage rive nord, femme de ménage rive sud
    femme de ménage tarif, prix femme de ménage ,recherche femme de ménage
    trouver femme de ménage ,service de nettoyage ,service de femme
    de ménage
    ,service de nettoyage Montréal ,service de nettoyage Laval, service de nettoyage rive nord
    ,service de nettoyage rive sud, service de nettoyage résidentiel ;service de nettoyage résidentiel Montréal ,service de nettoyage résidentiel rive nord ,service de nettoyage résidentiel rive sud
    service de nettoyage commercial ,service de nettoyage commercial Montréal, service de nettoyage commercial rive nord
    ,service de nettoyage commercial rive sud ;service
    de ménage ,service de ménage Montréal ; service de ménage
    rive nord ; service de ménage rive sud, services ménagers ;service de ménage
    résidentiel ,service de ménage commercial ,service d’entretien ménager
    ,service d’entretien ménager commercial ,service d’entretien ménager résidentiel ,
    service d’entretien ménager Montréal, service d’entretien ménager rive sud, service d’entretien ménager
    rive nord ;service de nettoyage maison ,entreprise de nettoyage

    Professionnelle de l’entretien, notre dynamique entreprise saura réaliser pour vous l’ensemble des travaux ménagers.

    Ménage Bio PRO s’engage sur une prestation de qualité !

    Notre équipe de spécialistes chevronnés accomplira un travail à
    la fois soigné, rapide et économique. De plus,
    nous utilisons exclusivement des produits écologiques et hautement performants,
    issus des toutes dernières technologies.

    Ménage Bio PRO met ses compétences à votre service pour l’entretien courant
    et occasionnel de vos résidences et locaux professionnels.os équipes
    de professionnels vous proposent des prestations de qualité adaptées à
    vos besoins.

    Grille de tarifs abordables : Nos prix sont
    optimisés pour avoir le meilleur rapport qualité/prix suivant vos besoins et les spécifications de votre résidence
    .

    Un personnel expérimenté et qualifié : Nos franchisés
    et équipes de nettoyage sont des professionnels formés pour répondre à vos besoins les
    plus spécifiques.

    Assurance responsabilité civile : Nos franchisés sont couverts par une assurance responsabilité civile garantissant les accidents ou dommages éventuels.

    Équipements et produits : Nos équipes utilisent leurs propres
    produits et équipements.

    Produits de nettoyage biodégradables et équipements : Protéger l’environnement est pour nous un objectif essentiel.

    Here is my page – nettoyage commercial ;entretien menager residentiel

  2. Darin dit :

    Hello i am kavin, its my first occasion to commenting anywhere,
    when i read this piece of writing i thought i could also make comment due
    to this brilliant paragraph.

    Here is my blog; Einweg-OP-Maske

  3. Cortez dit :

    My spouse and I stumbled over here from a different web address and thought
    I should check things out. I like what I see so now i’m following you.

    Look forward to exploring your web page again.

    Also visit my site: alcohol

  4. Clarence dit :

    Hiya! Quick question that’s completely off topic. Do you know how to make your
    site mobile friendly? My website looks weird when browsing from my apple iphone.

    I’m trying to find a theme or plugin that might be able to resolve this
    issue. If you have any suggestions, please share.
    Many thanks!

    my web site; Apollo Slots

  5. Oliver dit :

    Nicely wwritten & done.
    I started blogging very recentlly and realized that mny articles simply rework old content
    but add very little of value. It’s great too see a heloful article of sime genuine value to your
    readers and me.
    It is actually on the list of creteria I need to emulate being a new
    blogger. Audience engagement and material value are king.

    Some superb ideas; you have definitely made it
    on my lixt of people to follow!

    Carry onn the terrific work!
    Cheers,
    Barbi

    Alsoo visit my blog post; cellphones IMEI unloick [Felipa]

  6. Cecil dit :

    Nice post. I was checking continuously this blog and I am impressed!

    Extremely helpful information specifically the last part :
    ) I care for such info a lot. I was seeking this particular information for a long
    time. Thank you and best of luck.

    my website … Search Engine Optimization

  7. Marylin dit :

    Just want to say your article is as astounding. The clearness in your post is simply excellent and
    i could assume you’re an expert on this subject.
    Fine with your permission allow me to grab your feed to
    keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the rewarding work.

    Stop by my site Link Pkv

  8. Maurice dit :

    Hello! I’ve been reading your blog for a long time now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from Dallas Tx!
    Just wanted to mention keep up the good work!

    my page :: http://dichvuthetindung.vn/dao-han/dao-han-the-tin-dung-tai-quan-long-bien/

  9. Alba dit :

    Hey I know this is off topic but I was wondering if you knew of any widgets I could add to my blog that automatically tweet my newest twitter updates.
    I’ve been looking for a plug-in like this for quite
    some time and was hoping maybe you would have some experience with
    something like this. Please let me know if you run into anything.

    I truly enjoy reading your blog and I look forward to your new updates.

    Feel free to visit my web-site :: 먹튀검증

  10. bao reatimes dit :

    thank for share http://reatimes.vn

    reatimes.vn

  11. Morgan dit :

    Hi! Would you mind if I share your blog with my myspace group?
    There’s a lot of people that I think would really enjoy your content.
    Please let me know. Cheers

    Feel free to surf to my website :: http://dichvuthetindung.vn/dao-han/dao-han-the-tin-dung-tai-huyen-me-linh/

  12. Latasha dit :

    Hi admin,

    I just want to share this link shortener to everyone.
    We are registered company in NY and our link shortener
    can also be used as DDOS protection to your site. Shorten your website using our api and your
    site will be protected with any attacks possible.

    visit us at boo.re

    Also visit my blog post: shorter

  13. Carlo dit :

    Caan you telkl uus ore about this? I’d want to fond out ore details.

    my web site – MAKE MONEY DROP SHIPPING

  14. Kristofer dit :

    Hey there would you mind lettiing me know which wwbhost you’re using?

    I’ve loaded your blog in 3 completely different
    internet browsers and I must say this blog loads a lot faster then most.Can you suggest a good web hosting
    provider at a honest price? Thanks a lot, I appreciate it!

    Pm slotts web site club pm without registration

  15. Rod dit :

    Нi there, always i used to check website posts here in the early hours
    in the dawn, because i like to gain knowledge of more
    and morе.

    Herе is my page … college management system

  16. Hildegarde dit :

    Film streaming gratuit HD/4K en VF HDss,
    Film en streaming, Regarder meilleurs Films sur hdss.to GRATUIT.

  17. Charles dit :

    Download any videos online like youtube videos, facebook videos,
    twitter videos, instagram videos and many more.

    traynote.com

    My webpage: vimeo downloader

  18. India dit :

    Hello there, nice post ! I’ve shared it with people on my webpage,
    and they really liked it! Have a nice day.

    Also visit my web-site: psn gift cards giveaway 2020

  19. Brock dit :

    Greetings! Very helpful advice within this article! It’s the little changes which will make the largest changes.
    Thanks a lot for sharing!

    Here is my homepage … dieta nasoenteral

  20. Doretha dit :

    Hello, Neat post. There is an issue along with your web site in internet explorer, could check
    this? IE still is the market leader and a large component to other people will omit your great writing due to this
    problem.

    My website: 헌병대

  21. Cassie dit :

    I like the valuable info you provide in your articles. I will bookmark your weblog and check again here regularly.

    I’m quite sure I will learn many new stuff right here!
    Good luck for the next!

    my page … adul friend finder

  22. Lida dit :

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts on suara cucak ijo kicau.
    Regards

  23. Antwan dit :

    Hi, Neat post. There’s an issue together with your site in internet explorer, might test this?
    IE still is the market chief and a huge element of people will pass over your excellent writing due
    to this problem.

    My homepage :: sua glucerna cho người tiểu đường

  24. Daniele dit :

    I do noot even understand how I ended uup right
    here, however I assumed this put up was great.
    I don’t recognise who you might be but certainly you aare going
    to a famous blogger if you happeen to aren’t already. Cheers!

    Poker online poker the rules of gr poker online game

  25. Ronald dit :

    I just could not go away your website before suggesting that I actually enjoyed the usual information an individual supply for your visitors?
    Is gonna be back ceaselessly to check out new posts

    Feel free to visit my web-site :: NEXT001

  26. Jacelyn dit :

    Greetings! Very helpful advice in this particular post!
    It’s the little changes that make the most significdant changes.
    Thanks for sharing!
    site

  27. Louanne Smart dit :

    Guidance To Assist You To Explore The Planet Vacation may be a great way to increase your worldview and then make on your own. However, it does have its negative aspects, so correct prep is important. This information will give you prepare far better and be prepared for almost anything. Produce a checklist for your journey! If you are touring using a little international airport, verify their webpage to see every airline that they support. When traveling around other places, be suspicious of the items taxi cabs you receive into. Prior to deciding to basically enter in the automobile, you need to guarantee it’s a legitimate taxi. Let a household accessibility journey itinerary. This will tell them your whereabouts at on a regular basis. Continue to be in touch with that speak to being risk-free. They will know you’re secure in the event you routinely. A suitcases label hanging from the outside of your luggage can easily be conned in transportation. Take a book of complements or organization credit card out of your motel when you all the time. This is useful for what you may deficiency in communicating the local language. Provide a book of fits or company credit card along check out your spot city.This is useful for folks that do not are aware of the terminology well. Sign up for on the internet notifications available from most major airlines you like to use to travel. The price savings you may enjoy will a lot more than make up for having to deal with a few more products in your e-mail address. When you are having a long aeroplane trip, pack a couple of snacks. For those who have plenty of troubles while traveling, this may lead to stress. You could possibly be unable to obtain the proper automobile or routes may be postponed. The only real two who are able to resolve these problems have you been as well as the error. Make certain you work to fix the trouble, or else it might swiftly escalate in a major problem.Always keep relax and remain polite. This will make for yourself. There can be some protrusions in the process, but you can’t enable these have an impact on your trip. Just continue to keep these pointers under consideration when you travel, and you should certainly take pleasure in your holiday on the maximum level. You may basically get pleasure from paying attention more on your journey compared to organizing stage and that is certainly what it’s exactly about.

    https://blogfreely.net/crosscup84/travel-deal-tuesday-resembles-black-friday-for-trips

  28. Celina dit :

    Your way of explaining the whole thing in this article is
    in fact good, all be able to easily know it, Thanks a lot.

    Visit my page – Vanity mirror for bath

  29. Taylor dit :

    Hi there! Do you know if they make any plugins to assist
    with SEO? I’m trying to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but
    I’m not seeing very good results. If you know of any please share.
    Thanks!

    Also visit my web blog: http://dichvuthetindung.vn/dao-han/dao-han-the-tin-dung-tai-huyen-quoc-oai/

  30. Lila dit :

    Superb, what a weblog it is! This blog provides helpful data to us, keep it up.

    Here is mmy web site trying to get pregnant and succeeding
    meaning – Stanton -

  31. Freda dit :

    What’s up, the whole thing is going perfectly here and ofcourse
    every one is sharing data, that’s actually
    excellent, keep up writing.

    Also visit my blog post – marketing friuli venezia giulia

Laisser un commentaire

Fixutota |
Dictavsdemo |
Davidognw |
Unblog.fr | Créer un blog | Annuaire | Signaler un abus | Destbustestmang
| Igtenverssteel
| Gorkeroutu