Blood borders How a better Middle East would look BY RALPH PETERS .in :armedforcesjournal.com/juin 2006

http://www.armedforcesjournal.com/juin 2006

Blood borders

How a better Middle East would look

BY RALPH PETERS

International borders are never completely just. But the degree of injustice they inflict upon those whom frontiers force together or separate makes an enormous difference — often the difference between freedom and oppression, tolerance and atrocity, the rule of law and terrorism, or even peace and war.

The most arbitrary and distorted borders in the world are in Africa and the Middle East. Drawn by self-interested Europeans (who have had sufficient trouble defining their own frontiers), Africa’s borders continue to provoke the deaths of millions of local inhabitants. But the unjust borders in the Middle East — to borrow from Churchill — generate more trouble than can be consumed locally.

While the Middle East has far more problems than dysfunctional borders alone — from cultural stagnation through scandalous inequality to deadly religious extremism — the greatest taboo in striving to understand the region’s comprehensive failure isn’t Islam but the awful-but-sacrosanct international boundaries worshipped by our own diplomats.

Of course, no adjustment of borders, however draconian, could make every minority in the Middle East happy. In some instances, ethnic and religious groups live intermingled and have intermarried. Elsewhere, reunions based on blood or belief might not prove quite as joyous as their current proponents expect. The boundaries projected in the maps accompanying this article redress the wrongs suffered by the most significant “cheated” population groups, such as the Kurds, Baluch and Arab Shia, but still fail to account adequately for Middle Eastern Christians, Bahais, Ismailis, Naqshbandis and many another numerically lesser minorities. And one haunting wrong can never be redressed with a reward of territory: the genocide perpetrated against the Armenians by the dying Ottoman Empire.

Yet, for all the injustices the borders re-imagined here leave unaddressed, without such major boundary revisions, we shall never see a more peaceful Middle East.

Even those who abhor the topic of altering borders would be well-served to engage in an exercise that attempts to conceive a fairer, if still imperfect, amendment of national boundaries between the Bosporus and the Indus. Accepting that international statecraft has never developed effective tools — short of war — for readjusting faulty borders, a mental effort to grasp the Middle East’s “organic” frontiers nonetheless helps us understand the extent of the difficulties we face and will continue to face. We are dealing with colossal, man-made deformities that will not stop generating hatred and violence until they are corrected.

As for those who refuse to “think the unthinkable,” declaring that boundaries must not change and that’s that, it pays to remember that boundaries have never stopped changing through the centuries. Borders have never been static, and many frontiers, from Congo through Kosovo to the Caucasus, are changing even now (as ambassadors and special representatives avert their eyes to study the shine on their wingtips).

Oh, and one other dirty little secret from 5,000 years of history: Ethnic cleansing works.

Begin with the border issue most sensitive to American readers: For Israel to have any hope of living in reasonable peace with its neighbors, it will have to return to its pre-1967 borders — with essential local adjustments for legitimate security concerns. But the issue of the territories surrounding Jerusalem, a city stained with thousands of years of blood, may prove intractable beyond our lifetimes. Where all parties have turned their god into a real-estate tycoon, literal turf battles have a tenacity unrivaled by mere greed for oil wealth or ethnic squabbles. So let us set aside this single overstudied issue and turn to those that are studiously ignored.

The most glaring injustice in the notoriously unjust lands between the Balkan Mountains and the Himalayas is the absence of an independent Kurdish state. There are between 27 million and 36 million Kurds living in contiguous regions in the Middle East (the figures are imprecise because no state has ever allowed an honest census). Greater than the population of present-day Iraq, even the lower figure makes the Kurds the world’s largest ethnic group without a state of its own. Worse, Kurds have been oppressed by every government controlling the hills and mountains where they’ve lived since Xenophon’s day.

The U.S. and its coalition partners missed a glorious chance to begin to correct this injustice after Baghdad’s fall. A Frankenstein’s monster of a state sewn together from ill-fitting parts, Iraq should have been divided into three smaller states immediately. We failed from cowardice and lack of vision, bullying Iraq’s Kurds into supporting the new Iraqi government — which they do wistfully as a quid pro quo for our good will. But were a free plebiscite to be held, make no mistake: Nearly 100 percent of Iraq’s Kurds would vote for independence.

As would the long-suffering Kurds of Turkey, who have endured decades of violent military oppression and a decades-long demotion to “mountain Turks” in an effort to eradicate their identity. While the Kurdish plight at Ankara’s hands has eased somewhat over the past decade, the repression recently intensified again and the eastern fifth of Turkey should be viewed as occupied territory. As for the Kurds of Syria and Iran, they, too, would rush to join an independent Kurdistan if they could. The refusal by the world’s legitimate democracies to champion Kurdish independence is a human-rights sin of omission far worse than the clumsy, minor sins of commission that routinely excite our media. And by the way: A Free Kurdistan, stretching from Diyarbakir through Tabriz, would be the most pro-Western state between Bulgaria and Japan.

A just alignment in the region would leave Iraq’s three Sunni-majority provinces as a truncated state that might eventually choose to unify with a Syria that loses its littoral to a Mediterranean-oriented Greater Lebanon: Phoenecia reborn. The Shia south of old Iraq would form the basis of an Arab Shia State rimming much of the Persian Gulf. Jordan would retain its current territory, with some southward expansion at Saudi expense. For its part, the unnatural state of Saudi Arabia would suffer as great a dismantling as Pakistan.

A root cause of the broad stagnation in the Muslim world is the Saudi royal family’s treatment of Mecca and Medina as their fiefdom. With Islam’s holiest shrines under the police-state control of one of the world’s most bigoted and oppressive regimes — a regime that commands vast, unearned oil wealth — the Saudis have been able to project their Wahhabi vision of a disciplinarian, intolerant faith far beyond their borders. The rise of the Saudis to wealth and, consequently, influence has been the worst thing to happen to the Muslim world as a whole since the time of the Prophet, and the worst thing to happen to Arabs since the Ottoman (if not the Mongol) conquest.

While non-Muslims could not effect a change in the control of Islam’s holy cities, imagine how much healthier the Muslim world might become were Mecca and Medina ruled by a rotating council representative of the world’s major Muslim schools and movements in an Islamic Sacred State — a sort of Muslim super-Vatican — where the future of a great faith might be debated rather than merely decreed. True justice — which we might not like — would also give Saudi Arabia’s coastal oil fields to the Shia Arabs who populate that subregion, while a southeastern quadrant would go to Yemen. Confined to a rump Saudi Homelands Independent Territory around Riyadh, the House of Saud would be capable of far less mischief toward Islam and the world.

Iran, a state with madcap boundaries, would lose a great deal of territory to Unified Azerbaijan, Free Kurdistan, the Arab Shia State and Free Baluchistan, but would gain the provinces around Herat in today’s Afghanistan — a region with a historical and linguistic affinity for Persia. Iran would, in effect, become an ethnic Persian state again, with the most difficult question being whether or not it should keep the port of Bandar Abbas or surrender it to the Arab Shia State.

What Afghanistan would lose to Persia in the west, it would gain in the east, as Pakistan’s Northwest Frontier tribes would be reunited with their Afghan brethren (the point of this exercise is not to draw maps as we would like them but as local populations would prefer them). Pakistan, another unnatural state, would also lose its Baluch territory to Free Baluchistan. The remaining “natural” Pakistan would lie entirely east of the Indus, except for a westward spur near Karachi.

The city-states of the United Arab Emirates would have a mixed fate — as they probably will in reality. Some might be incorporated in the Arab Shia State ringing much of the Persian Gulf (a state more likely to evolve as a counterbalance to, rather than an ally of, Persian Iran). Since all puritanical cultures are hypocritical, Dubai, of necessity, would be allowed to retain its playground status for rich debauchees. Kuwait would remain within its current borders, as would Oman.

In each case, this hypothetical redrawing of boundaries reflects ethnic affinities and religious communalism — in some cases, both. Of course, if we could wave a magic wand and amend the borders under discussion, we would certainly prefer to do so selectively. Yet, studying the revised map, in contrast to the map illustrating today’s boundaries, offers some sense of the great wrongs borders drawn by Frenchmen and Englishmen in the 20th century did to a region struggling to emerge from the humiliations and defeats of the 19th century.

Correcting borders to reflect the will of the people may be impossible. For now. But given time — and the inevitable attendant bloodshed — new and natural borders will emerge. Babylon has fallen more than once.

Meanwhile, our men and women in uniform will continue to fight for security from terrorism, for the prospect of democracy and for access to oil supplies in a region that is destined to fight itself. The current human divisions and forced unions between Ankara and Karachi, taken together with the region’s self-inflicted woes, form as perfect a breeding ground for religious extremism, a culture of blame and the recruitment of terrorists as anyone could design. Where men and women look ruefully at their borders, they look enthusiastically for enemies.

From the world’s oversupply of terrorists to its paucity of energy supplies, the current deformations of the Middle East promise a worsening, not an improving, situation. In a region where only the worst aspects of nationalism ever took hold and where the most debased aspects of religion threaten to dominate a disappointed faith, the U.S., its allies and, above all, our armed forces can look for crises without end. While Iraq may provide a counterexample of hope — if we do not quit its soil prematurely — the rest of this vast region offers worsening problems on almost every front.

If the borders of the greater Middle East cannot be amended to reflect the natural ties of blood and faith, we may take it as an article of faith that a portion of the bloodshed in the region will continue to be our own.

• • •

WHO WINS, WHO LOSES

Winners

Afghanistan

Arab Shia State

Armenia

Azerbaijan

Free Baluchistan

Free Kurdistan

Iran

Islamic Sacred State

Jordan

Lebanon

Yemen

Losers —

Afghanistan

Iran

Iraq

Israel

Kuwait

Pakistan

Qatar

Saudi Arabia

Syria

Turkey

United Arab Emirates

West Bank

Ralph Peters is the author of the new book “Never Quit the Fight,” to be published on July 4th

6  746 Réponses à “Blood borders How a better Middle East would look BY RALPH PETERS .in :armedforcesjournal.com/juin 2006”

  1. Antonietta dit :

    If some one wants tto be updated with newest technologies therefore he must be payy a visit this website and bbe up to date everyday.

    Have a look at my webpage … how to sing better pitch singer
    (Lydia)

  2. Shelli dit :

    Ahaa, its pleasant discussion on the topic of this piece
    of writing at this place at this website, I have read all that, so now me
    also commenting here.

    Feel free to visit my website … części komputerowe

  3. Randal dit :

    Witth havin so much writen content do you ever run into any issuees
    oof plagorism or copyright violation? My website has a lot of completely unique content I’ve either created mysef or outsourced
    but iit seems a lot of it is popping it up all over the ijternet without my agreement.
    Do you know anyy ways tto help reduce content from being stolen? I’d definitely appreciate it.

    My web-site :: brainpilll reeview (Home.changchi.win)

  4. Eli dit :

    That is a really good tip particularly to those fresh to the blogosphere.
    Short but very precise info… Appreciate your sharing this one.
    A must read post!

    Stop by my homepage :: adultfriend finder login

  5. Tabitha dit :

    Hey there I am so delighted I found your blog page, I really found you by error,
    while I was searching on Yahoo for something else, Nonetheless I
    am here now and would just like to say cheers for a fantastic post and a all
    round interesting blog (I also love the theme/design), I don’t have time to
    look over it all at the minute but I have bookmarked
    it and also added in your RSS feeds, so when I have time I will be back to read more, Please do keep up the awesome
    job.

    Here is my website; bank of america

  6. Mittie dit :

    Hello, i think that i saw you visited my weblog thus i came to
    “return the favor”.I’m trying to find things to enhance my site!I
    suppose its ok to use some of your ideas!!

    My web site – sbobet

  7. Kara dit :

    No matter if some one searches for his vital thing, thus he/she wants to be available that in detail,
    therefore that thing is maintained over here.

    Here is my web page :: ยิงปลา

  8. Jetta dit :

    I was suggested this web site by my cousin. I am not sure
    whether this post is written by him as no one else know such deetailed about
    my difficulty. You’re incredible! Thanks!
    Suisse онлайн казино website онлайн-игры для мобильных казино

  9. CBD for sale dit :

    Great blog post. Cool.

    https://royalcbd.com/

  10. Alexandria dit :

    Amazing! Its truly awesome paragraph, I have got much clear idea
    about from this piece of writing.

    Check out my webpage – bieganie

  11. Muhammad dit :

    Cryptocurrency details takes a long haul this is going to happen to take management over their cash.
    We take an account you can start receiving Bitcoin because of that a Bitcoin alternate.
    De-corrupting charities in your account identical
    to Paypal permit US to digitally alternate. The plots have several wallets are located on the alternate you would like to buy Bitcoin’s then.
    Then reality hits before lengthy it dawns on the budding
    digital forex the transaction. Security is the foreign money or digital coins which are the inventors
    or tinkerers and they are going to be. However
    that volatility might be a risky affair as a result of cryptocurrencies are getting used
    to develop with them. Cryptocurrencies work the same Bitcoin protocol and methodology of transferring cash to one another.
    The idea for the signatures can work in the direction of constructing a platform one is.
    • quite a few new crypto coins by means of an ICO to fund
    Ripple’s platform improvement company or buy.

    my website … https://postheaven.net

  12. Roland dit :

    If some one wishes expert view concerning blogging then i recommend
    him/her to visit this weblog, Keep up the fastidious job.

    Also visit my blog: i99betm1

  13. Chandra dit :

    Amazing! Its genuinely remarkable paragraph, I have
    got much clear idea about from this article.

    Here is my web blog – parque conchagua

  14. Ernestine dit :

    Today, I went to the beach with my kids. I found
    a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said
    « You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear. » She put the
    shell to her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her
    ear. She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is totally
    off topic but I had to tell someone!

    Feel free to surf to my page; bitcoin price

  15. Tonya dit :

    This post will help the internet visitors for setting up new webpage or even a weblog from start to end.

    my blog … http://vigormalexlp.com/

  16. Ladonna dit :

    Hi, I read your new stuff like every week. Your writing style is witty, keep doing
    what you’re doing!

    Here is my site :: http://goodguysgiftcard.bravesites.com/

  17. Myron dit :

    I used to be suggested this web site by my cousin. I am not positive whether this
    putt up is written through him as no one else know such exact about my problem.
    You are wonderful! Thanks!

    My web-site … natürliche produkte gegen unreine haut

  18. Augustina dit :

    I am truly glad to glance at this webpage posts which contains plenty of valuable
    information, thanks for providing such data.

    Here is mmy blog; wesley young fat diminisher reviews

  19. Sterling dit :

    Hey very nice blog!

    Also visit my web site: Situs Bandarq Online

  20. Parbrize HYUNDAI MATRIX FC 2005 dit :

    Excellent post. I will be going through many of these issues
    as well.. https://vanzari-parbrize.ro/parbrize/parbrize-hyundai.html

  21. Juliana dit :

    Hi there this is kind of of off topic but I was wondering if
    blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually code with html read more.
    I’m starting a blog soon but have no coding knowledge
    so I wanted to get advice from someone with experience.

    Any help would be enormously appreciated!

  22. Derick dit :

    I’m really inspired together with your writing abilities and also with the
    format for your blog. Is this a paid topic or did you modify it
    your self? Anyway keep up the nice high quality writing,
    it’s rare to see a great blog like this one today..

    Feel free to surf to my web-site :: types of casino games

  23. Susanna dit :

    What’s up, after reading this remarkable article i am aalso happy to share my familiarity here with mates.

    Feeel free to visit my homepage; dr amend’s pheromone advantage review

Répondre à Dirk

Fixutota |
Dictavsdemo |
Davidognw |
Unblog.fr | Créer un blog | Annuaire | Signaler un abus | Destbustestmang
| Igtenverssteel
| Gorkeroutu